Editorial Error in Source Text: Misattribution of "Cherwit Make" in Pima Mythology Excerpt Autor vlákna: Ricardo Aries
|
|---|
Ricardo Aries 
Indonésie
Local time: 21:48
Člen (2020)
angličtina -> indonéština
+ ...
Hi everyone,
I wanted to flag a clear editorial error in a source text excerpt based on Charles M. Skinner’s Myths and Legends of Our Own Land (1896), specifically the Pima legend "The Ark on Superstition Mountains."
I’m sharing this in case anyone else encounters this passage or similar parenthetical misattributions in working source texts.
The Passage in Question:
"There was one Hauk, a devil of the mountains, who stole their daughters an... See more Hi everyone,
I wanted to flag a clear editorial error in a source text excerpt based on Charles M. Skinner’s Myths and Legends of Our Own Land (1896), specifically the Pima legend "The Ark on Superstition Mountains."
I’m sharing this in case anyone else encounters this passage or similar parenthetical misattributions in working source texts.
The Passage in Question:
"There was one Hauk, a devil of the mountains, who stole their daughters and slew their sons. […] He (Cherwit Make) silently followed him into the Superstition Mountains; he drugged the cactus wine that his daughter was to serve to him; then, when he had drunk it, Suha emerged from his place of hiding and beat out the brains of the stupefied fiend."
The Narrative Contradiction:
Cherwit Make is the creator deity (the butterfly spirit who creates humanity from sweat and later sends the flood).
Suha is the patriarch/human ancestor whose daughters were abducted by the mountain devil Hauk.
Inserting (Cherwit Make) after "He" creates an immediate plot contradiction: if Cherwit Make was the one pursuing Hauk and arranging the drug with his daughter, Suha suddenly stepping out of hiding at the end to execute Hauk makes no sense.
Checking the 1896 Original:
In Skinner’s original publication, the preceding sentence reads:
"The patriarch, whose patience had been taxed to its limit, then made a vow to slay the devil. [...] He silently followed him..."
Here, "He" unambiguously refers back to "The patriarch" (Suha), not Cherwit Make. A later editor misread the pronoun reference and inserted (Cherwit Make) in brackets.
In short, it’s a clear case of an editor attempting to 'clarify' an ambiguous pronoun and accidentally breaking the narrative logic instead. ▲ Collapse
| | | |
Toto fórum nemá žádného přiřazeného moderátora.
Chcete-li nahlásit porušení pravidel serveru nebo získat pomoc, obraťte se na
pracovníky serveru ».
Editorial Error in Source Text: Misattribution of "Cherwit Make" in Pima Mythology Excerpt
| TM-Town | Manage your TMs and Terms ... and boost your translation business
Are you ready for something fresh in the industry? TM-Town is a unique new site for you -- the freelance translator -- to store, manage and share translation memories (TMs) and glossaries...and potentially meet new clients on the basis of your prior work.
More info » |
|
| Trados Business Manager Lite | Create customer quotes and invoices from within Trados Studio
Trados Business Manager Lite helps to simplify and speed up some of the daily tasks, such as invoicing and reporting, associated with running your freelance translation business.
More info » |
|
Login to reply/comment 
